| 2019 | Position | College |
| Kaelyn Whitten | OF | Humboldt State (Academics) |
| 2018 | ||
| Isabella Gregson | P | Chico State (Academics) |
| Brandi Almaraz | SS | La Sierra University |
| Sloane Greeley | OF | Marymount California Univ. |
| 2017 | ||
| Monica Salas | Infield | Univ. of New Mexico |
| Sydney Townes | OF | Univ. of New Mexico |
| Lauren "Hope" Ballard | OF | Chapman University |
| Alyssa Richter | SS | Metro State (Colo.) |
| Maggie Jackson | OF | Long Beach State (Acadmics) |
| Madison McNamee | P | Cal St. Channel Islands (Academics) |
| 2016 | ||
| Christal Vierra | 3B | Sacramento State University |
| Alexa Sorensen | 1B | Sonoma State University |
| Amanda Caras | 2B | Cal State Channel Islands |
| 2014 | ||
| Alice Cen | Shortstop | Loyola Marymount |
| Paige Harley | Utility | University of Calgary |
| Nicole Bennett | OF | University of Calgary |
| Shannon Kelly | OF | University of Nevada-Reno |
| Brianna Gill | OF | San Francisco State |
| Victoria Lucido | Infield | Cal State Monterey Bay |
| Alexandra Abbott | Pitcher | University of Indiana |
| 2013 | ||
| Jasmyne Holmes | 2B/1B | CSU Monterey Bay |
| Jennifer Stevens | OF | Cal State Northridge |
| Alyse Harris | Pitcher | Hawaii Hilo |
| Mariah Coyazo | 2B | San Diego State |
| Carly Smith | OF | Univ. of Nevada-Las Vegas |
| 2012 | ||
| Nicole Adair | OF | CSU East Bay |
| Lisa Zeitlin | Infield | San Diego State |
| Elicity Fabing | OF | San Diego State |
| 2011 | ||
| Kailey Snyder | Pitcher | Colorado State |
| Laura Cannon | Shortstop | UC Davis |
| Joan Cannon | OF | UC Davis |
| Lauren Takayesu | OF | USC |
| Amanda Sharp | 1B | Sonoma State |
| 2010 | ||
| Crystal Ruiz | OF | UC Riverside |
| Liliana Caughman | Pitcher | North Dakota State |
| Janelle Wong | Catcher | Minot, N.D. |
| 2009 | ||
| Erin Breck | Infield | University of Tennessee |
| Kacie Muro | Catcher | Cal State Bakersfield |
| Jennifer Mosier | OF | Cal State Northridge |
| 2008 | ||
| Stephanie Garcia | OF | Cal State Bakersfield |
